Review: Fashioning Fat by Amanda Czerniawski


NYU Press
23rd January 2015

Price:24.00 USD


For two and a half years, Amanda Czerniawski was a sociologist turned plus-size model. Journeying into a world where, as a size 10, she was not considered an average body type, but rather, for the fashion industry, “plus-sized,” Czerniawski studied the standards of work and image production in the plus-sized model industry. Fashioning Fat takes us through a model’s day-to-day activities, first at open calls at modeling agencies and then through the fashion shows and photo shoots. Czerniawski also interviewed 35 plus-size models about their lives in the world of fashion, bringing to life the strange contradictions of being an object of non-idealized beauty.

Fashioning Fat shows us that the mission of many of these models is to challenge our standards of beauty that privilege the thin body; they show us that fat can be sexy. Many plus-size models do often succeed in overcoming years of self-loathing and shame over their bodies, yet, as Czerniawski shows, these women are not the ones in charge of beauty’s construction or dissemination. At the corporate level, the fashion industry perpetuates their objectification. Plus-size models must conform to an image created by fashion’s tastemakers, as their bodies must fit within narrowly defined parameters of size and shape—an experience not too different from that of straight-sized models. Ultimately, plus-size models find that they are still molding their bodies to fit an image instead of molding an image of beauty to fit their bodies. A much-needed behind-the-scenes look at this growing industry, Fashioning Fat is a fascinating, unique, and important contribution to our understanding of beauty.

Amanda M. Czerniawski is Assistant Professor of Sociology at Temple University.


Professor Czerniawski’s exploration and analysis of the ‘plus-size’ modelling world is unique, I understand, and gives the reader an insight into a rather shadowy and ‘informal’ profession. There was a good balance between experiencial description and analysis. Especially important to this study are the words of professional models, whose greater experience provide an important depth.

While reading the book I formed an opinion of models, agents and the fashion world which I noticed was later echoed by the words of models themselves. Models, whether ‘plus-size’ or ‘straight-size’ adapt their bodies to the demands of customers and agents; photographs are retouched to hide reality. Their lives are lived at the behest of their agents, removing much personal choice. Women who could be role models for body acceptance are sucked into the toxic world of fashion and contribute to the negative images portrayed of women.


Published by

R Cawkwell

Hi I'm Rosemarie and I like to write. I write short stories and longer fiction, poetry and occasionally articles. I'm working on quite a few things at the minute and wouldn't mind one day actually getting published in print.

Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s