Review: Bad Santas and other creepy Christmas characters, by Paul Hawkins

Simon & Schuster


1600 years in 258 A5 pages. It’s not a huge amount of space but Paul Hawkins manages to pack his book with information, including selected bibliography, index and notes/references sections.



The purpose of this book…is not to criticise Santa’s influence…but rather to highlight the range of fantastic myths and folk stories that have existed around Christmas within Europe and
across the world.

Page 9

‘Disquieting winter folk tales for grown-ups’

So it says above the title; this description does not do Paul Hawkins’ book justice. In addition to recounting various European Christmas folk tales, he also covers their origins and development, the origins and influences of Christmas as a festival, Saint Nicholas, and finally the development of Santa Claus in  early nineteenth century New York and his spread around the world.

I really enjoyed this intelligent and informative little book. The stories in it are amusing and slightly creepy. The diversity of winter stories from across Europe makes a pleasant change to the usual sugar-laden Christmas tales that abound. The Krampusse, rampaging through Austria, getting drunk and beating people up sound much more fun than a jolly fat man sneaking down chimnies delivering spoilt children loads of toys.

There was definitely a bit more of the winter in these medieval creatures; they were dark and punishing like the season, and just as likely to kill children. The festivities they were part of allowed people to let off steam and invert the social order in rigidly stratified agrarian societies. With old gods and new devils running around causing trouble people could get away with quite a few things they wouldn’t ordinarily try. Eventually there had to be a crack down and Christmas as a festival and the creatures that went with it were banned or scaled back. Only with the rise if the Victorian middle classes, and their desire for a ‘respectable’ way to celebrate a ‘traditional’ Christmas, without the drunken disorder so prevalent in the past, did the modern Christmas come into being.

This book isn’t just a retelling of folktales, it’s a history of Christmas itself. Well worth reading.

(I found only small irritations in this book. The copy I have is a proof copy, therefore I shall politely not mention the odd errors. They’ve probably been sorted out now, or at least I should hope so. There were also odd historical inaccuracies, such as the repeated claim that people went to found colonies in North America to escape persecution in England. Many of the ‘Pilgrims’ left for America because they thought England, and the Anglican Church, wasn’t strict enough. The mistakes are generally those common ones that pass as ‘common knowledge’ or ‘everyone knows’, but are usually wrong. Other than that, no complaints from me.)


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s